Rhode Island Made Coffee Milk Its State Drink in 1993. 7 More Local Foods That Confuse Visitors

We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post. This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive a small commission at no extra cost to you ... you're just helping re-supply our family's travel fund.

Order a “cabinet” in Providence and you will get a milkshake. Ask for a hot wiener and you will get something that is neither hot in the spicy sense nor quite a hot dog. Rhode Island foods to try start with coffee milk, the official state drink, and a short list of local dishes that confuse almost every first-time visitor.

Coffee milk got its official status on July 29, 1993, according to the state’s official symbols page. It is made like chocolate milk, but with sweet coffee syrup stirred into cold milk. The state notes that coffee milk was first introduced to Rhode Islanders in the early 1920s, and it became so popular that the legislature voted it the official state drink in 1993. Wikipedia’s history of the drink adds a detail locals love: the two finalists for state drink were coffee milk and Del’s Lemonade, and coffee milk won.

So, coffee milk first. Then here are the seven foods that make visitors ask, “Wait, what is that?”

How Coffee Milk Works

Coffee milk is simple. You pour coffee syrup into a glass of cold milk and stir, the same way you would make chocolate milk with chocolate syrup. The syrup is made from coffee, sugar, and water, cooked down until thick and sweet. It tastes like a very sweet, mild iced coffee, with much less caffeine than a cup of brewed coffee.

The best-known brand is Autocrat, a Rhode Island company that has been family-owned since 1895 and also owns the Eclipse brand. You can buy a bottle at nearly any grocery store in the state, and many Rhode Islanders keep one in the fridge. Diners and some restaurants serve coffee milk by the glass, and some convenience stores sell it premixed in cartons.

• How to order it: Just ask for “coffee milk.” No one will be confused.
• Where to buy syrup: Any Rhode Island supermarket. A pint bottle is cheap, usually well under $10 at a local store.
• How to pack it: Coffee syrup is a liquid, so bottles over 3.4 ounces must go in checked bags if you are flying home.

7 More Local Foods That Confuse Visitors

Each of these is genuinely local, and each has a name or form that surprises people from other states.

1. The Coffee Cabinet

A cabinet is Rhode Island’s word for a milkshake: ice cream blended with milk and syrup. A coffee cabinet uses coffee syrup and coffee ice cream, and the state’s own symbols page describes it as coffee milk with ice cream. If you order a “milkshake” in some older Rhode Island diners, you might get just milk and syrup shaken together, without ice cream. The word cabinet is often linked to the wooden cabinets where blenders were once kept, though no one is sure of the origin.

2. Hot Wieners

Rhode Island hot wieners are small pork and veal sausages served in steamed buns with a meat sauce, chopped onions, mustard, and celery salt. They are often called New York System wieners, even though they have no real link to New York; the name was a marketing choice by early Greek immigrant shop owners in the 1900s. Order them “all the way” for the full set of toppings. Locals tend to order three or four at a time, and many shops pair them with coffee milk. Olneyville New York System in Providence is one of the best-known spots.

3. Stuffies

A stuffie is a stuffed quahog clam. Quahogs are large hard-shell clams found in Narragansett Bay. To make stuffies, cooks chop the clam meat and mix it with breadcrumbs, onions, peppers, herbs, and often chouriço, a Portuguese sausage common in southeastern New England. The mixture is packed back into the half shell and baked. Squeeze lemon and add hot sauce. You will find stuffies at seafood shacks, in grocery store freezer cases, and at nearly every summer clam shack in the state.

4. Clear Clam Chowder

Most visitors know two chowders: New England (white and creamy) and Manhattan (red, with tomatoes). Rhode Island has a third, served at many restaurants: clear clam chowder. It has a clear broth made from clam juice, with clams, potatoes, onions, and sometimes bacon or salt pork. Some menus call it “Rhode Island clam chowder.” Many locals think it lets the clam flavor come through best. Order it with clam cakes, which are fried fritters full of chopped clams, on the side.

5. Pizza Strips

Walk into a Rhode Island bakery, especially in Providence’s Federal Hill or in towns with strong Italian-American roots, and you will see long rectangles of thick, focaccia-like bread topped with a sweet tomato sauce and no cheese. These are pizza strips, also called bakery pizza or party pizza. They are served at room temperature and sold by the strip or by the sheet. They are a staple at birthday parties and family gatherings, and they make no sense to visitors expecting a hot cheese pizza.

6. Johnnycakes

Johnnycakes are cornmeal pancakes, and Rhode Island takes them seriously. They are traditionally made with white cap flint corn, a local heirloom variety, ground into meal and mixed with water or milk. There are two regional styles: thin and lacy versions associated with the East Bay, and thick, soft versions associated with South County. Johnnycakes are served with butter or maple syrup, usually at breakfast. Kenyon’s Grist Mill in Usquepaugh, which has operated for well over a century, still grinds johnnycake meal.

7. Del’s Frozen Lemonade

Del’s is the runner-up for state drink, and it is a Rhode Island institution. Frozen lemonade is a slushy mix of shaved ice, lemon juice, sugar, and bits of lemon. The Del’s company traces its recipe to Italy and began selling in Rhode Island in 1948. You will see Del’s carts at beaches and fairs and its stands across the state. The drink is mostly a summer thing, but some stands and grocery stores sell it year-round. Locals sip it from the cup without a straw.

Rhode Island Foods to Try in One Day: A Providence Plan

Here is a one-day plan around Providence that covers most of the list:

• Breakfast: A diner with johnnycakes and a glass of coffee milk.
• Midmorning: A bakery on Federal Hill for pizza strips and Italian pastries.
• Lunch: Hot wieners “all the way” with coffee milk at a New York System shop.
• Afternoon: A drive south toward Narragansett or Galilee for clam cakes and clear chowder at a seafood shack.
• Evening: A coffee cabinet at an ice cream shop or a diner.

Expect a full day of eating to cost about $40 to $70 per person, depending on how many places you visit. Hot wieners are inexpensive, often a few dollars each, while seafood shacks charge more for chowder, clam cakes, and stuffies.

Why Rhode Island Food Is So Specific

Rhode Island is the smallest state, and its food culture reflects a small number of strong immigrant communities living close together. Italian-Americans shaped the bakeries and Federal Hill. Portuguese and Cape Verdean communities brought chouriço and seafood traditions. Greek and Macedonian immigrants ran many of the early hot wiener shops. The local clam beds in Narragansett Bay made quahogs cheap and plentiful. Because the state is so compact, these traditions blended into one shared local food culture rather than staying in separate regions.

Coffee milk fits that pattern. A cheap, sweet syrup became a regional habit in the 1920s, spread through diners and corner stores, and stuck around long enough that lawmakers made it official in 1993.

A Few More Local Terms

Rhode Island’s food vocabulary goes beyond these seven items. A few more words come up on menus and in conversation:

• Grinder: A sub or hoagie sandwich, common across southern New England.
• Bubbler: Some Rhode Islanders use this word for a drinking fountain.
• Dynamite: A sloppy-joe-style sandwich of ground beef, peppers, onions, and tomato sauce, associated with Woonsocket.
• Saugy: A brand of natural-casing hot dog that snaps when you bite it, popular at summer stands.
• Doughboys: Fried dough tossed in sugar, a staple at clam shacks and beaches.

Bringing It Home

If you want to bring Rhode Island food home, a few options travel well:

• Coffee syrup: Pack in checked luggage or ship it. Bottles are sturdy but wrap them in clothing.
• Johnnycake meal: Sold in bags at grocery stores and gift shops. It is a dry good and fine in a carry-on.
• Frozen stuffies: Some grocery stores sell them frozen. Bring a cooler for a car trip.
• Del’s mix: Some stores sell Del’s lemonade mix in bottles.

The Bottom Line

Coffee milk is the easy entry point: sweet, cheap, and on almost every diner menu. Once you have tried it, work through the cabinet, the hot wiener, the stuffie, clear chowder, pizza strips, johnnycakes, and Del’s. You will understand why Rhode Islanders defend their food so fiercely, and you will know what to order the next time someone hands you a menu written in local code.