We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post. This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive a small commission at no extra cost to you ... you're just helping re-supply our family's travel fund.
From a distance, these islands look like daydreams: turquoise shallows, perfect reefs, and empty strips of sand that never see a beach chair. Up close, they sit behind layers of law, barbed wire, or ecological protections that keep ordinary visitors far away. Some hide toxic legacies or military runways; others shelter fragile wildlife or tightly guarded communities. Together, they show that even in a country built on road trips and open spaces, a few places are meant to be watched only from the map’s edge.
Niihau, Hawaii, The “Forbidden Island”
Niihau sits just off Kauai, close enough to see on a clear day yet effectively sealed to most outsiders. The island is privately owned, home to Native Hawaiian families who maintain language and traditions with minimal outside influence. Occasional helicopter or snorkeling tours skirt the coast but do not grant free roaming on land. For the general public, Niihau exists as a silhouette on the horizon and a reminder that not every Hawaiian shore is for sale.
Kahoolawe, Hawaii, Bomb Range Turned Sacred Restoration Site
Kahoolawe once thundered with explosions as a U.S. Navy bombing range, leaving craters, unexploded ordnance, and eroded slopes. After intense activism, the island was returned to the state of Hawaii for cultural and environmental restoration, not mass tourism. Access is tightly controlled by the Kaho‘olawe Island Reserve Commission, with only select volunteer crews and cultural practitioners allowed ashore under strict rules. To everyone else, it remains a powerful story of repair unfolding behind a deliberate no-entry line.
Palmyra Atoll, Pacific Remote Islands
Palmyra Atoll looks like a classic South Pacific fantasy, all coconut palms, coral reef, and shallow lagoons, but nearly all of it is a protected wildlife refuge. The atoll is co-managed by U.S. federal agencies and a conservation nonprofit, focused on research and habitat restoration. Access is limited to staff, scientists, and a few permitted visitors who arrive on chartered flights or vessels. Cruise ships and casual yachts are turned away, leaving seabirds and reef sharks as the primary regulars.
Wake Island, Western Pacific
Wake Island appears on flight maps as a tiny refueling dot between Hawaii and Asia, but it functions as a secure U.S. military outpost rather than a travel stop. The atoll holds runways, radar facilities, and housing for contractors and personnel under Department of Defense control. There are no hotels, guided tours, or welcome desks for curious travelers. Entry requires official authorization, and unauthorized boats or aircraft are intercepted long before they can treat the airstrip as a novelty layover.
Johnston Atoll, Central Pacific
Johnston Atoll carries one of the heaviest legacies in the Pacific, having hosted nuclear tests, missile programs, and chemical weapons storage during the Cold War era. Cleanup efforts removed much infrastructure, and the atoll is now managed as a remote wildlife refuge with lingering contamination concerns. No commercial flights or passenger ships stop here, and landing without permission is both illegal and dangerous. For most people, Johnston exists only as a cautionary footnote about what gets left behind after big arsenals move on.
Navassa Island, Caribbean
Navassa Island sits between Haiti and Jamaica, claimed by the United States but uninhabited and ringed by steep, treacherous cliffs. Historically, it hosted guano mining and a lighthouse; now it functions as a national wildlife refuge with sensitive coral reefs and nesting seabirds. Hazardous terrain, lingering disputes, and conservation priorities mean there is no regular access for tourists or recreational boaters. In practical terms, Navassa remains a name on nautical charts and a restricted speck in warm blue water.
San Nicolas Island, California
Far off the Southern California coast, San Nicolas Island looks like it belongs with the national park–protected Channel Islands but instead operates as a U.S. Navy installation. The island supports test ranges, training areas, and infrastructure closed to the public for safety and security reasons. Even researchers negotiate complex permissions, and there are no civilian ferries or campgrounds. The stories of Indigenous inhabitants and later residents now coexist with restricted airspace and patrols that keep curious boaters well away from its shores.