This New York Town Has Two Lucy Statues Because the First Caused an Uproar

We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post. This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive a small commission at no extra cost to you ... you're just helping re-supply our family's travel fund.

Scenic view of York with prominent cathedral spires under cloudy skies.
Celoron’s two Lucy statues reflect a do-over that became a lasting local attraction. The village kept the original after commissioning a replacement, leaving fans with two very different tributes to Lucy. The story starts with a familiar comedy character and a statue that missed the mark. For visitors, the pair offers more than a photo stop. It shows how a hometown tribute can become part of the story it was meant to honor. Celoron grew up in the public eye through Lucy’s work on I Love Lucy, and the town still welcomes fans who come to see where she spent her childhood.

Key Takeaways

  • Celoron kept the original statue and installed a replacement.
  • The original statue became known as Scary Lucy.
  • The replacement is officially New Lucy, also called Lovely Lucy.
  • Both statues stand outdoors at Lucille Ball Memorial Park.
  • The park has no admission charge and offers on-site parking.
The contrast between the two tributes is part of what draws visitors to Lucille Ball’s childhood hometown.

Why Lucille Ball statues Celoron New York Became a Local Controversy

The first statue chose one of Lucy Ricardo’s best-known comic moments, but its face became the story. Celoron residents saw a bronze tribute to Lucille Ball that looked far unsettling to many people who knew her face. The village installed the life-size sculpture in 2009. Its comic pose came from a famous I Love Lucy scene, but residents felt the likeness did not look like Ball.

A comic scene cast in bronze

The statue shows Ball as Lucy Ricardo holding a bottle of Vitameatavegamin. Vitameatavegamin is the fictional health tonic Lucy Ricardo advertises in the I Love Lucy episode “Lucy Does a TV Commercial.” In the 1952 episode, Lucy films a television advertisement for the tonic. She tastes more of the product as the commercial goes on, and her delivery grows increasingly loose and silly. That scene gave the statue a clear link to the show. The bottle and pose made the reference easy for fans to recognize, even before they knew the episode title.

Why the likeness failed

Sculptor David Poulin made the original statue, aiming to capture Ball in a memorable comic role. Residents criticized its face and expression, which they felt looked unlike the actor. The gap between the idea and the result mattered. A well-known comedy pose might have felt like a warm nod to Lucy, but the face struck many locals as unsettling instead.
A recognizable scene cannot carry a tribute if the likeness distracts from the person it honors.

For longtime viewers, the statue’s odd look became hard to separate from the joke it was meant to celebrate. The episode reference explains the bottle and pose, while the disputed likeness explains the uproar.

How the First Statue’s Backlash Spread

The criticism began locally, then a social-media campaign gave it a much larger audience. The Facebook campaign against Scary Lucy began in 2012, several years before images spread widely online. For a time, objections stayed tied to the town and its visitors. The campaign gave residents a shared way to press for change, and the sculpture became a public issue rather than quiet local grumbling.
YearTurning pointResult
2012Facebook campaign opposes the statueCriticism gains an organized public presence
2015Images go viral and receive international coverageThe controversy reaches a broader audience
2015Poulin apologizes and offers a no-charge fixThe mayor declines and selects another sculptor
In 2015, photos went viral and drew international media coverage. The attention turned a town dispute into a story that fans well beyond New York could follow. As the backlash grew, Poulin publicly apologized and offered to fix the statue at no charge. A WBUR report on Poulin’s offer described his response to the criticism. Mayor Scott Schrecengost declined the offer and chose a different sculptor. The town’s decision to hire a different sculptor made a fresh tribute the next step.

Who Made the Replacement, and What Does It Show?

Celoron chose sculptor Carolyn Palmer after reviewing proposals from more than 65 artists. The town wanted a recognizable image of Lucy, not another tribute that left visitors debating the face. The replacement statue is a seven-foot bronze figure in a polka-dot dress, standing on a Hollywood star. The design presents Ball as a glamorous star rather than as one of her comic characters.

Choosing Carolyn Palmer

Celoron considered more than 65 sculptors before selecting Palmer. The search set a high bar for the new statue because the town wanted a likeness fans could recognize at a glance. The village announced Palmer’s selection on August 1, 2016. Her design made Ball’s face and star status the focus, giving the tribute a different tone from the earlier statue. Palmer’s bronze work stands seven feet tall. Ball wears a polka-dot dress and stands on a Hollywood star, a familiar symbol of her career in entertainment.

Designing a more recognizable Lucy

The new statue was unveiled on August 6, 2016, which would have been Ball’s 105th birthday. Hundreds of fans attended the event, bringing a crowd to welcome the new tribute. The unveiling drew people who had followed the controversy as well as Lucy fans who wanted to honor her. NPR’s report on the new statue covered Palmer’s selection and the birthday event. Private donations paid the full $250,000 cost. That funding gave the project a clear community role, with supporters helping pay for the statue rather than relying on public funds. The birthday unveiling gave fans a public moment to welcome a tribute designed to look unmistakably like Lucy.

Why Did Celoron Keep Both Lucy Statues?

Celoron kept the original because the controversy turned it into an attraction in its own right. The village kept the original on display beside the replacement, allowing visitors to see the story’s two outcomes in one park. The original is called Scary Lucy, while the replacement is officially New Lucy and also goes by Lovely Lucy. The replacement received a warmer response, but the older statue still draws visitors.
AttributeOriginal statueReplacement statue
Public nameScary LucyNew Lucy and Lovely Lucy
Park positionMoved nearbyPlaced in the original spot
Visitor responseContinues to draw visitorsReceived more positively
Town’s choiceKept on displayInstalled as the new tribute
The original statue’s continued presence does not mean Celoron treats it as an equal likeness. Its place in the park reflects the public reaction that made it famous, and visitors still come to judge it for themselves. Keeping both makes the park a small record of the town’s changing choices. Seeing both in the same park makes the town’s decision legible without treating the first statue as if it had disappeared.

Where Can You See the Statues in Celoron?

Both statues stand in Lucille Ball Memorial Park at 21 Boulevard Avenue in Celoron. The lakeside village park sits on Chautauqua Lake, and visitors can find the sculptures outdoors within the grounds. There is no admission charge, and on-site parking is available. The statues remain outdoors year-round, so weather can shape the comfort of a visit.

Finding the statues at Lucille Ball Memorial Park

Use the address 21 Boulevard Avenue, Celoron, NY 14720, to reach the park. Once inside, look for the two sculptures in the park; they are displayed near one another, without needing a long walk between them. About 20 minutes is a reasonable amount of time to see both statues. Visitors who want to linger by the lake or use other park features should allow more time.

What else the park offers

The public park includes several places to play, rest, or take in the lake. Its amenities include:
  • A lighthouse, boat launches, and docks
  • A playground and picnic tables
  • An accessible boardwalk and accessible restrooms
  • A ball field and basketball courts
  • A bandshell and grills
The park also has a kayak launch, picnic shelter, and on-site parking. Its outdoor setting makes it easy to pair the statues with a short walk along the water. Allow about 20 minutes for the statues, with extra time if you want to enjoy the lakeside park.

What Else Can Lucy Fans Visit Nearby?

Celoron is where Lucille Ball grew up, while nearby Jamestown is where she was born. Ball was born at 60 Stewart Avenue in Jamestown on August 6, 1911, making the birthplace a separate stop from the statues. Jamestown offers three key stops for Lucy fans:
  • Ball’s birthplace at 60 Stewart Avenue
  • The Lucy Desi Museum
  • The National Comedy Center
The museums add context on Ball’s work and comedy, while the birthplace connects visitors with her early life. Jamestown also hosts the Lucille Ball Comedy Festival each August.
If attending the August festival matters, plan the Jamestown stop around its event dates.
Jamestown and Celoron are neighboring places with different parts of Ball’s local story. Treat the birthplace as a historic stop and the museums as the deeper dive into her career.

Conclusion

Celoron’s two statues turn a public-art misstep into an unusually candid tribute to Lucy. The first sculpture’s survival is part of the town’s unusual story: it remains visible, rather than being erased after the replacement arrived. For fans, seeing both offers a chance to form a view beyond the headlines. The park holds the messy history and the newer tribute in one place, with no admission fee standing between visitors and the sculptures. If you are in the area, stop at Lucille Ball Memorial Park and see both for yourself.

FAQ

Is there an admission fee at Lucille Ball Memorial Park?

No, Lucille Ball Memorial Park and its statues are free to visit. The park is a public village park, so visitors can stop to see the sculptures without buying a ticket. On-site parking is available, and the statues stand outdoors year-round. Bring weather-appropriate clothing if you plan to spend extra time by Chautauqua Lake.

How long should I plan to see the two statues?

About 20 minutes is a reasonable amount of time to see both statues. That allows time to view each sculpture and take a few photos. Visitors who want to walk along the lakeside boardwalk or explore other park features should plan to stay longer. The extra time depends on how much of the public park they want to enjoy.

Is parking available at Lucille Ball Memorial Park?

Yes, on-site parking is available at Lucille Ball Memorial Park. The park sits at 21 Boulevard Avenue in Celoron, and drivers can use that address to reach the entrance. The statues are outdoors within the park grounds, so visitors can continue on foot after parking. The park also has a kayak launch, boat launches, and docks.

Are the statues displayed outdoors year-round?

Yes, both statues remain outdoors year-round. Their outdoor setting means visitors can see them in every season, though winter weather may make walking around the park less comfortable. Check local weather and road conditions before a winter visit, and dress for the lake’s conditions. The park does not charge admission to see the sculptures.

Does Lucille Ball Memorial Park have a kayak launch?

Yes, Lucille Ball Memorial Park has a kayak launch, along with boat launches and docks. The launch gives paddlers access to Chautauqua Lake, while the statues offer a separate stop within the same public park. Visitors who plan to paddle should bring their own kayak and gear. The park also has an accessible boardwalk and on-site parking.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.